Review: Forever Evil by Geoff Johns

Forever EvilForever Evil by Geoff Johns

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I’ve got a friend who claims you’d have to be a booger-eating, poo-flinging, Shallow Reader to actually enjoy Geoff Johns’ latest offering.
Nay, I say!
Actually, I said ‘nay’ right after I ate my booger and threw some poop on him….so he may have a point.

*shrugs, wipes hands on jeans*

This was F-U-N!
At the end of Trinity War, the Crime Syndicate (Earth-3 evil versions of the JL) pops up and overtakes the Justice League.
One big flash of light later, and the entire Justice League disappears! So, who’s left to fight these guys?
Well, Lex Luthor, for one. In fact, he’s pretty much the star of this show.
The entire story is one giant fight between our bad guys and their bad guys! And that means the real question is: Are Earth’s villains evil enough?!

 I loved the tone of Forever Evil. It never stopped, never got dull, and you never knew what was going to happen next.
And, as an added bonus, there are going to be plenty of ripple effects left over from this event to keep things in the DC universe interesting for a long time to come. I’m especially excited to find out what’s going to happen with the Nightwing storyline!

Now, don’t get me wrong, not every member of the Justice League totally disappears for the entire book. And on the side of the true heroes, Batman and Catwoman stole the show.
Although, Catwoman might not be getting an invite to join the Justice League anytime soon, I still consider her on the side of the angels… Pbbbbt!

Also, between Grayson and Selena, you get to see a different side of Batman.
While the banter between Catwoman kept things light, the way he felt about Nightwing moved me. In most of the more recent titles I’ve read, it felt like Batman would always choose Save-The-World over Save-Your-Friend. It was logical, but cold. In this, I felt like Bruce would have let the world burn in order to get Grayson out of danger.
And, honestly, I loved it.

Why only 4 stars?
Truth time.
As my poo-covered friend so eloquently pointed out, there are holes.
Massive, glaring, idiotic…Plot Holes.
Now, as you know, I can overlook things like the moon being able to block out the sun…indefinitely. Because I don’t particularly care that all that stuff rotates independently, thus making the placement of the moon in front of the sun, as a permanent solution to sunlight, fairly ridiculous.
And if that were the only ‘hole’, I would just scoff at my condescending friend for his haughty attitude toward a comic book.
Unfortunately…God, it’s physically painful to say this. It’s like there’s a chunk of something stuck in my throat
He’s *GAK* right.
There were too many unbelievable moments not admit that there were problems with this thing. Instead of coming up with a more logical reason to destroy shit, kidnap people, and keep powerful enemies alive, what you got was this:
Mwhahaha! Because we’re EEEVIL, that’s why!
Ok. I admitted it. Happy now?!

But I’m not letting this review go out on a sour note!
On the whole, this was a massively fun romp that totally captivated my attention. No, it’s not perfect, but if you’re not someone with a giant stick stuck in your ass, you’ll have a good time with Forever Evil.

View all my reviews


2 thoughts on “Review: Forever Evil by Geoff Johns

  1. *loud wail* You won’t believe this, Anne. I got approved for the ARC of this book, but they approved it like half an hour before midnight and the next day it got archived on Netgalley. I woke up, saw the approval email, got all excited and went over to see nothing. Zip. Nada.
    It’s official. DC has something against me.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s